%!$ Easy Diy Woodworking Bench Plans For You #!@

pocket-hole-jig-vs-biscuit-joiner I make quick jigs, temp shop furniture, etc Conversely, when it comes to pocket screw joinery, the only way to mask visible screws is by popping in wooden inserts and painting over them to match pockeh color of the furniture. Share Tweet Facebook. The biscuit joiner will make "hidden" connections while the Kreg holes will have pocket hole jig vs biscuit joiner be covered up some way. There is no cost to you for using these links. Last edited by cabinetman ;AM.

Kreg Foreman The Kreg Foreman is great for the serious builder who needs to drill lots of pocket holes quickly. A biscuit joiner or plate joiner has a small horizontally mounted saw blade. When the biscuit joiner is pushed into a workpiece the blade cuts a half-moon shaped slot. Then the biscuit joiner is positioned on the corresponding workpiece and the blade is pushed into the workpiece which cuts the second half of the slot.

Glue is applied to a thin football shaped wafer called a biscuit. The biscuit is placed into the slots and the joint is clamped until the glue dries. A biscuit joiner can cut three sizes of slots. In my opinion, the best feature of a biscuit joiner is the way it can precisely align joints. Flush fitting joints rely completely on tightly clamping your project. Special pocket hole clamps and face clamps are available, but I typically use an assortment of bar clamps and scrap wood as cauls for tightly clamping my pocket hole projects.

The Kreg Jig allows much more flexibility with the joint location because you only need to drill pocket holes on one side of the joint. With a biscuit joiner, you need to cut a biscuit slot on both sides of the joint and this could get a little tricky with some joints. If you used a Kreg Jig you would drill pocket holes on the ends of the short cleats, clamp to the long cleat and drive some pocket hole screws. If you used a biscuit joiner you would first cut biscuit slots on the ends of the short cleats.

We can place the cleats on our workbench, clamp them to the bench, plunge the biscuit joiner into the workpiece and cut the biscuit slot. Next comes the tricky part of cutting biscuit slots on the long cleat. The biscuit slots need to be cut in the face of the long cleat which requires a slightly different approach.

Removing the guard could cause the slot to be misaligned which means it might not match up to the slot in the short cleat. So how do we do it? We would need to place the cleat so it hangs off the edge of our workbench, clamp the workpiece to the bench and cut the slot. In other words, the slot might accidentally be cut at an angle. This could cause the slot in the short cleat not to properly line up with the slot in the long cleat making for a poor fitting joint.

I have used both pocket hole joints and biscuit joints when building my DIY furniture projects and my observation is the joints are equally strong. First, biscuit slots are cut, glue is applied to the biscuit, inserted in the slots and the joint is clamped. Then pocket holes are drilled through the joint and pocket hole screws are attached. I have never tried this technique, but it seems like it would create a doubly strong joint.

With the biscuit joiner, you need to cut two biscuit slots one on each side of the joint. Next glue is applied to the biscuit, the biscuit is inserted in the slots and the joint is clamped. Then you have to wait for the glue to dry. Using pocket hole joinery might allow you to build a project on a weekend versus a week or two when building with a biscuit joiner. For me, the Kreg Jig has a biscuit joiner beat on speed. When thinking about if a Kreg Jig vs a biscuit joiner is easier to use I look back to our cleat example.

In that example, we drilled some pocket holes with a Kreg Jig and assembled the cleat. To make the same cleat assembly with a biscuit joiner we first cut biscuit slots in the short cleats. Then we had to reposition to cut slots in the face of the long cleat and then assemble the cleats. By now you probably already have a guess which joinery method I prefer. I still use my biscuit joiner from time to time, but hands down nearly all of my projects are built with my Kreg Jig.

There are some unique differences between a Kreg Jig and biscuit joiner. A biscuit joiner does a great job of properly aligning the faces of workpieces, but in my opinion, a Kreg Jig is faster, easier to use and my preferred joinery method for building my DIY projects. Thank you for stopping by. If you found this information helpful, would you please pin it to Pinterest?

Other DIYers would appreciate it and I would too! Thank you — Scott. How to Edge Join with Pocket Holes. Biscuits win on that one hands down. They are invisible from the start. To hide a kreg joint, you have to glue in a plug, sand it, add wood filler, wait again and sand again.

I love my kreg jig because I tend to err on the side of speed and practicality, but man are those joints ugly.

Hi Ben — Thank you for stopping by. Awesome review Scott! As always, you are clear and detailed. This has been so helpful! Keep up the great work and I look forward to your reviews! Another advantage to the bisquit joinery is there is no tell-tail hole to fill and sand.

And even then they show unless your paint the item. Hi Mark — Thank you for stopping by. Great post, Scott! I love my Kreg Jig. If your joint will be seen from both sides, the biscuit joiner might provide a cleaner look. I vote for the kreg jig. U will find a lot if uses for it. Plus, it'll create a much stronger joint than a biscuit. Honeydokreg over on festool owners group has some great vids on built ins.

He uses a kreg jig for a lot of the joinery. His stuff looks great. He does a lot of high end installs. I have been using the porter cable biscuit joiner a lot lately. I also have the kreg jig, which I use mostly for face frame work.

Is your built in going to be face frame? I have both and without knowing more about the project it's hard to say. The biscuit joiner will make "hidden" connections while the Kreg holes will have to be covered up some way. The Kreg Pocket Hole Jig Joinery Instagram is fast, although you can move pretty quickly with a biscuit joiner and some experience. You can use the biscuit joiner for things like alignment, cutting slots for keys in mitered corners and other kinds of detail work.

I shelled out for a Domino during a reconditioned sale and now try to use it whenever possible to amoratize the cost, so I know that works as well. Biscuit joiner is a more versatile machine. Even when pocket holes are filled with plugs they still look tacky. And they should only be used on projects in which they're acceptable anyway.

For some built-ins in a closet they're fine as long as the holes are hidden. Or for face frames, etc. Anything you wanna call fine furniture should be all wood joinery so it's moot. Great tool It is basically just going to be a single floor to ceiling cabinet the is 3 feet wide. The bottom is going to be one big drawer for a clothes hamper. Then There will be a row of 2 normal sized drawers. Above that there will be shelves.

I will be making a face frame for around the drawers. I know that I can build it using the pocket holes without them being seen. But I see myself using the biscuit joiner more on future projects. You can certainly use the biscuit joiner for attaching the face frames to the cabinet. As for constructing the face frame itself, Pocket Hole Jig Vs Biscuit Joiner For Sale you can use the biscuit joiner if you have the porter cable or a similar model that can accept a cutter for ff biscuits. If I remember correctly, I think you can go as small as 1.

For a general construction project like a closet, and seeing as the pocket screws will be hidden, I see no reason why they could not be utilized. I do agree with Eric however, pocket screws shouldn't go into fine furniture. If I could only choose one of the two tools, I would choose a biscuit joiner.

Just make sure you get a high quality one. I have had the porter cable for 8 years, and it is still as good as it was the day I got it. Very hardy, accurate, and it comes with some nice accessories in the box. It also will accept a ton of different biscuit options. Biscuit joiners are one of those things that are less handy than they seem considering you still have to clamp and it's alignment qualities are overrated. I like it for attaching face frames or building lightweight shelving, that's it.

I decided that I'm going to build the cabinets the right way. I just need to decide whether to do it with my cheap Ryobi Router or go ahead and get the Porter Cable 2. I personally think that is a good choice. That makes this a skill building project as well as a practical one. Thats exactly what I was thinking Cindy. I was a little afraid to take that next step but it is one that is necessary and fundamental to being a woodworker. While I don't plan on building cabinets on a regular basis it will be good to know that I have those skills to do the job and they can be applied to the fine woodworking that I enjoy doing.

I still love having my Kreg mini. Just the one hole jig that you manually clamp. Although not fine woodworking, it comes in handy really offer. Really worth it.

RJ, This reminds me of a time I was learning to use a cross cut sled in a class I was taking. The length was oversized so it wasn't critical that I cut it exact, but I was taking time to cut exactly to the line I had marked. The instructor pointed out that the length wasn't critical and said I shouldn't be wasting that time. I was a brand new woodworker, when should I learn how to cut exactly, when it really matters? I take every opportunity to practice proper technique even when it doesn't matter so it is second nature when it does.

It does the job a bit slower but it will work in areas that a full sized jig will not. If you are cutting dados with your router a few Kreg screws could make your install a lot easier. I used both the kreg jig and biscuit cutter tonight.

I Simply cut 2 biscuits in each shelf and mating edging, added some glue, and pocket screwed from underneath to avoid clamps. Anyhow, both are very handy. For the closet project either could work. I'm going to argue that the biscuit joiner is the most misused tool in anyone's shop.

The biscuit joiner is an alignment tool. I see people use them as a joinery tool and it makes me cry. Do me a favor and at least router in a dado for the fixed shelves in the closet. And if you ever joint up a table top and want to align it with biscuits, glue your joint, not your biscuits.

Biscuits were made to strengthen the joints of particle board and for the assembly of particle board cabinetry. It was the New Yankee Workshop that made both of these popular.

Somerfield came out with the Kreg jig and its popularity became popular. Neither were actually designed for what people use them for today on a daily basis but they do work. Biscuits are helpful when aligning pieces to be joined with screws. For table tops they can be very helpful for the home shop guy that doesn't have panel flatteners.

This doesnt mean they dont work. The purist in me will say they have a place and that is in particle board for biscuits and in face frames for pocket holes. I dont use use either a whole bunch but do have both machines. For leveling panels biscuits work but v grooving and dappering works much better. If your planting panels biscuits work just fine but really need to be followed up with the proper mechanical fastener.

The reality is they can be used any place you want to use them. The key to any joinery is understand the limitations.

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. Paste as plain text instead. Only 75 emoji are allowed. Display as a link instead. Clear editor. Upload or insert images from URL. Reply to this topic Start new topic. Prev 1 2 3 Next Page 1 of 3.

Chest Freezer Lid Wont Close Printable Woodworking Templates Zero Electric Belt And Disc Sander 85 Carpentry Jobs In Kitsap County